Skip to main content

Posts

“If you had sex you have to except responsibility and keep the baby” is basically the prolife version of the “she was asking for it” argument for rape

The “she was asking for it” argument is basically that a woman was asking to get raped if she chose to wear skimpy or provocative clothing. It’s her own fault. Saying that having consensual sex means you have to carry to term & can't have an abortion is basically the “she was asking for it” argument for forced continued pregnancy. Saying a woman was asking for it by wearing provocative clothing is faulty because women are raped while wearing all sorts of clothing, including burkas. It is rapists that cause rape. It follows her actions, but is separate and distinct from her actions. Saying that a person is asking to get pregnant by having consensual sex is faulty because a person can get pregnant from non consensual sex too. It is a biological process that causes pregnancy. It follows her actions, but is separate and distinct from her actions. Telling women to just not have sex is like telling women to not dress in provocative clothing. Except it’s more than that. It’s telling t...

Human rights do not conflict; Human rights have their respective boundaries and they end where another human's rights begin

This is a common argument that I see, that if a right conflicts with another right, we have to tie break those rights essentially. But there is no tie breaking needed because human rights don't conflict with one another. You have a right to life, so long as it does not require violating someone else's rights. So for example, a person trying to rape someone else does not "forfeit" their right or conflict with the rights of their victim. They actually just don't have the right to life in the act of raping someone because it required them to violate someone else's rights in order to carry out the act of rape. Their RTL extends until they violate the rights of someone else. Their RTL does not extend into areas that violate someone else's rights. And this is different than saying "They have the RTL and that right is violated for the greater cause of ending a rape." This "Youth for Human Rights" website breaks down human rights in simple bul...

Response to Pro-life Argument "Ordinary vs. Extraordinary Care"

Prolife argument: "The womb is designed precisely to keep the fetus alive. When there's a fetus inside the womb, the womb is serving its bodily function." Response: Sure. And the vagina is "designed" to be a sheath for a penis. You are violating it if the person to whom the vagina belongs does not wish for a penis to be inside it. Likewise with a uterus. The "Ordinary vs Extraordinary Care" argument is not only faulty, but repulsive. It perpetuates the notion that the female body was meant to be used by others. That parts of her were "designed" for someone else & that that somehow makes it that "someone else's" property.  Her body was meant for her utilization for when she sees fit. When she wishes for a penis to be in her vagina, she then utilizes her vagina's function by allowing someone inside it. When she wishes for a fetus to be in her womb, she then utilizes her womb's function by allowing for someone to gesta...

Fetuses never qualified for human rights to begin with

 I am sure many of us on this sub have encountered the silly concept that "a fetus is not a human." At first, I thought it was just some silly, outdated concept being used by people not well versed in the debate, something to just look past. Now I realize that it is, indeed, an outdated concept, but not one we should just look past. That phrase tells us a lot about our history on the discussion of, not just humans, but human rights. The idea of "human rights" came about during times when the idea that the unborn were not human was still widely held. (This is where that outdated argument came from.) The concept of human rights never included fetuses. The concept of human rights came about during these times, when fetuses were not included in the concept of "human." And this is further supported by the fact that abortion was not seen as a similar crime or sin to that of murder throughout history. There has always been a marked difference between that of born...

The fundamental flaw with the prolife argument

The argument of the prolife movement is that of right to life. According to wikipedia, "The right to life is the belief that a being has the right to live and, in particular, should not be killed by another entity including government." But the sentiment of "right to life" is highly misleading, specifically in the abortion debate. The defining factor for prolife is not life or death.  It's action. Herein lies the issue with the prolife argument. The prolife movement should have life at it's foundation. However, upon further examination, it actually has another foundational block underneath that, and that is about  preventing people from doing things that they deem as wrong.  It is about action vs inaction. If life can be saved through action, it is not permissible if it violates someone's bodily autonomy. Why? Because that would then involve  doing something wrong  (taking action.) But if life can be saved through inaction (such as banning abortion), it ...

Crosswalk example illustrating women with unwanted pregnancies as being innocent

The person hit in the crosswalk arrives at the hospital: Doctor: What were you doing, walking outside like that? Crosswalk person: I was walking to the grocery store. Doctor: Why didn't you take Marble st. instead of City ave. City ave. has a lot of fast cars on it and if you hadn't been there, this car wouldn't have hit you. Crosswalk person: Sorry, I just wasn't thinking clearly about it at the time. Doctor: And why were you walking to the grocery store anyway? Did you need to go to the grocery store? Where you out of groceries or were you just going to get soda? Crosswalk person: Um... I am not sure what that has to do with anything cause I need help regardless, but since you ask, I was going to get soda. Doctor: Well sorry, but we cant help you. You should have thought about what street to take and if it was really necessary before you decided to walk to the grocery store. Going to the grocery store for soda isn't a good enough reason to get access to medical ca...

Parthood view of pregnancy makes more sense than the containment view

  This will be a summary of a journal called Were you a part of your mother? that discusses two different views on the relationship between a pregnant person and a fetus. This journal entry refers to the pregnant person as the gravida and the fetus as the foster, so I will be referring to them with those terms as well. One view is the containment view and the other is the parthood view. The containment view seems to be a fairly commonly held view, one that I have seen both sides of the argument hold, so I will be focusing on the parthood view. I believe that the parthood view has a stronger logical standing. I will be summarizing it below by following the four criteria presented for what makes something a whole organism and what is a part of that whole organism. Following that will be the objections and how they can be addressed. I will not address every piece of criteria presented, but will do my best to condense down key points of this 55 minute read. Here is a mini table of co...