Skip to main content

Legal understanding on the use of Lethal Force and how it relates to abortion

(sourced from the prochoice subreddit in June of 2023) 

Legal writing (especially a statute) is NOT like having a conversation. Words are not interchangeable!


There are thousands of appellate level cases interpreting language. We have rules for how you do that. It’s not arbitrary. Judges have to follow the rules, which are called “canons of construction.”


[Students new to law school have to learn when writing] that they can’t change words to give their writing variety like they might do in English class, because they will change their legal conclusions.


In other words, the selection of words and punctuation is very crucial to law and are specifically chosen so that they cannot be substituted out for another word which might change the intended meaning.


Key components:


  • Imminence criteria provides for inevitability, with temporal variances that may or may not be immediate, but is impending nonetheless. While immediate simply refers directly to the next step in a sequence of events.
  • Proportionality criteria provides for the differentiation between degree of force vs effect of that force

To begin, the elements of any legal defense or any crime or any tort are never arbitrary. They all exist for a reason. The elements stated above make sense when evaluating whether force used in self-defense against a born person is justified. There is a clear underlying rationale for each element... We know that the interaction between a fetus and a woman are different in significant, material factual ways from the interaction between two born people. Therefore, we cannot simply take a superficial look at the elements of self-defense designed to apply to situations between born people and determine whether these self-defense criteria can also apply to interactions between fetuses and women. We must consider the principles underlying these criteria so that we can properly apply them to the factually distinct situation between a woman and a fetus.


The use of lethal force is limited when it comes to born people in part because there are usually many ways to avoid a threat of harm or unwanted contact without having to resort to lethal force. If someone is poking me, I can walk away. I could push them. I could take their hand and stop the poking. If a child is hitting me, I can restrain them and put them in their room. If someone is exuding noxious gasses, I can walk away from them. Generally speaking, between born people, the only situations where there do not exist alternate ways to stop the threat/unwanted contact short of lethal force are those situations where you are at imminent risk of serious harm.


Imminence

Let’s focus on the imminence requirement, which is raised a lot by prolifers. You all argue that if there even is any harm from pregnancy, it’s not imminent. It’s in 9 months, or maybe never. Therefore, according to prolifers, pregnancy does not meet the criteria for self-defense. This analysis is superficial. The imminence requirement is there for a reason, but we need to consider what the reason is. Generally speaking, between two born people, if an attack is immediate and imminent there is no other way to avoid the harm than using some type of force in self-defense. You can’t go to the cops and say someone threatened you and get a temporary restraining order. You can’t walk away from them. You can’t have a conversation with them to deescalate. The exact same thing is true for pregnancy -- there is no way to avoid the harm other than removing the ZEF. This is the case even though the most severe harm (birth) is not immediate. (Although I would argue that any non-consensual use of the body that is presently happening is certainly immediate and imminent harm.) Imminence and immediate are not synonymous, even though imminent harm is often immediate. To sum up: the reason imminence is a requirement is that when something is imminent, there isn't another chance to avoid the threat except for the use of force. Pregnancy satisfies this element. Birth will happen. It’s unavoidable except for abortion. The unwanted contact is currently happening.


Proportionality

Now, let’s take the proportionality criteria. First, I note that use of lethal force in self-defense isn’t limited to situations where you have a reasonable fear of death. You can also use lethal force in self-defense from serious bodily harm. All pregnancies result in serious bodily harm. More importantly, in pregnancy, there is no way to stop the unwanted contact/threat that will not result in the death of the fetus. We know a non-viable fetus will die when removed.


Prolifers make the mistake of confusing the degree of force with the effect of that force. The basic principle of self-defense is that you have the right to stop a threat. This is a pretty basic concept: even if the threat doesn’t rise to the level of lethal harm or severe bodily harm, we understand that people have the right to protect themselves or remove themselves from unwanted bodily intrusions, such as rape, battery, medical battery. That’s why I ask prolifers to point out situations where we are not permitted to separate ourselves from forces that are physically harming us. A woman would be within her rights to simply separate herself from any born person who was harming her. Such separation very often does not require lethal force, and born people do not simply die from separation. Separation is a minimal amount of force. Unlike born people, however, fetuses die when separated from women. The fetus's need for her organs does not change the nature of the force (removal) applied; it only changes the outcome of the force applied.


If you claim that a woman cannot remove the fetus because it will die, then this is completely incompatible with her right to separate herself from something causing her harm. It obliterates her right to use even the most minor force to protect herself. [The prolife] argument means that the fetus's neediness totally negates a woman's rights to exercise self-defense in any capacity whatsoever, in any amount of force, which is a pretty serious conclusion [they've] done nothing to support. She can do nothing. She just has to sit there and take all the harm, because the fetus needs her body to live.


Proportionality is more complex than “is the harm you’re doing or trying to do to me worse than the harm I’ll do to you if I try to stop you.” The law asks us whether the force used is excessive, not just whether the effect of the force is better or worse than the harm sought to be avoided. Necessity is a crucial component of the analysis. What other options does the woman have? None. It’s wrong to use more force than you need to to stop a threat. That’s why we don’t kill kids who try to pull our hair. It’s unnecessary. We can avoid the harm with less force. It’s wrong to kill a born person when you can easily stop the harm with a smaller amount of force. This is not the case with pregnancy. You cannot stop the harm short of removing the fetus.


[Contribution by SuddenlyRavenous, a lawyer]

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

''Why Mothers Don’t Have The Right To Refuse Babies The Use Of Their Wombs'' & a rebuttal as to why they actually do

My rebuttal is to this Federalist article: ''Why Mothers Don’t Have The Right To Refuse Babies The Use Of Their Wombs'' This prolife article argues that prenatal humans have to belong somewhere. If not the womb, then where? ''For most pro-choice advocates, the right to abortion hinges on affirming that a pregnant woman has the right to refuse her child residence in her body. But then the question may be asked, if a prenatal human being does not belong in her mother’s womb, where does she belong? The answer? Nowhere.'' You can ask that if you wish. My answer would be that it is irrelevant to the very first statement. ''It is implausible to claim a child does not belong in the place she began to exist and the only place she can survive: in the nurture and care her mother’s body naturally provides. This has been the case for virtually all of humanity since our history began. The mother’s womb is the rightful place of a child in t...

Pro-choice Arguments for Debate

( sourced from the prochoice subreddit in June of 2023)  #Common Prolife Arguments ___________________________________________________________________________________ ##Pregnancy is Natural **PL Argument:**  > Pregnancy & birth is natural and therefore, it is immoral to interfere or interrupt that process.  Women are adapted to have children. **PC Reply:**  So is getting eaten by a hungry cougar, but most would intervene should they see such about to occur. [Contribution by o0Jahzara0o] **PC Reply:**  Something being natural does not make it good or ethical. Cyanide is natural, does that mean it's good to die from being poisoned by it? The human body is, to put it bluntly, piss-poor at reproduction. Our heads are too big for how narrow our pelvises are so we're born before we're done developing (hence why newborns are so helpless compared to other animals). Tying into this argument is "Abortion is not natural", to which I say: Miscarriage. Miscarriage is ...

The fundamental flaw with the prolife argument

The argument of the prolife movement is that of right to life. According to wikipedia, "The right to life is the belief that a being has the right to live and, in particular, should not be killed by another entity including government." But the sentiment of "right to life" is highly misleading, specifically in the abortion debate. The defining factor for prolife is not life or death.  It's action. Herein lies the issue with the prolife argument. The prolife movement should have life at it's foundation. However, upon further examination, it actually has another foundational block underneath that, and that is about  preventing people from doing things that they deem as wrong.  It is about action vs inaction. If life can be saved through action, it is not permissible if it violates someone's bodily autonomy. Why? Because that would then involve  doing something wrong  (taking action.) But if life can be saved through inaction (such as banning abortion), it ...