Skip to main content

Similarities & differences surrounding abortion; what connects us and what divides us?

I think it is grounding and humanizing to remember we all hold similar moral frameworks and that, despite drastically different view points, there are commonalities we all hold. Let's start with the similarities we hold in the area of exceptions.

Pro life believes life matters above all else..
But within that community, they allow for exceptions as well and these exceptions vary as to what they are and who holds them.
  • Rape
  • Incest
  • Medical need of the mother
  • Medical issues with the fetus
There is of course those that believe there are no exceptions no matter the reason.

Pro choice believes life matters as well, but allows for additional exceptions. These exceptions vary as well as to what they are and who holds them.
  • Psychological harm
  • Financial hardships
  • Timing errors
And here as well, there are people who believe that all exceptions should be allowed no matter the reason.
In some ways, the different exceptions could actually fall under similar exceptions within the opposing communities. For example, rape and incest could fall under psychological harm, just a specific kind. Incest could be seen as a specific kind of financial hardship if the person pregnant were a minor family member. Medical needs could be seen as a specific kind of timing error.

Are there other ways in which we are similar? Why do we argue so much and what are we really arguing over?

I posted the above exception similarities & asked these questions of the reddit community and from there, some differences started to emerge. The above outlines a spectrum of exceptions and both groups fall at various points along that spectrum. Three questions emerged from this:

  1. Where on the spectrum of exceptions do we set the barometer at?
  2. Who gets to make the decision of were the barometer gets set, the woman or another person(s)?
  3. What moral lens do we use in which to view the circumstances leading to, and the meaning of, pregnancy to begin with?
Three things seem to be fueling the debate surrounding abortion.
  • Moral views of circumstances and meaning of pregnancy
which influence the
  • Spectrum of exceptions that set our barometers
which influence our belief of
  • Who gets to make the decision, the woman or another person(s)

Some of this stuff might be rather obvious to some while not to others. I felt it was a good, sobering exercise to present the issue in a more neutral manner to pull some of the emotion out of a very charged subject and just present the argument.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

''Why Mothers Don’t Have The Right To Refuse Babies The Use Of Their Wombs'' & a rebuttal as to why they actually do

My rebuttal is to this Federalist article: ''Why Mothers Don’t Have The Right To Refuse Babies The Use Of Their Wombs'' This prolife article argues that prenatal humans have to belong somewhere. If not the womb, then where? ''For most pro-choice advocates, the right to abortion hinges on affirming that a pregnant woman has the right to refuse her child residence in her body. But then the question may be asked, if a prenatal human being does not belong in her mother’s womb, where does she belong? The answer? Nowhere.'' You can ask that if you wish. My answer would be that it is irrelevant to the very first statement. ''It is implausible to claim a child does not belong in the place she began to exist and the only place she can survive: in the nurture and care her mother’s body naturally provides. This has been the case for virtually all of humanity since our history began. The mother’s womb is the rightful place of a child in t...

Pro-choice Arguments for Debate

( sourced from the prochoice subreddit in June of 2023)  #Common Prolife Arguments ___________________________________________________________________________________ ##Pregnancy is Natural **PL Argument:**  > Pregnancy & birth is natural and therefore, it is immoral to interfere or interrupt that process.  Women are adapted to have children. **PC Reply:**  So is getting eaten by a hungry cougar, but most would intervene should they see such about to occur. [Contribution by o0Jahzara0o] **PC Reply:**  Something being natural does not make it good or ethical. Cyanide is natural, does that mean it's good to die from being poisoned by it? The human body is, to put it bluntly, piss-poor at reproduction. Our heads are too big for how narrow our pelvises are so we're born before we're done developing (hence why newborns are so helpless compared to other animals). Tying into this argument is "Abortion is not natural", to which I say: Miscarriage. Miscarriage is ...

The fundamental flaw with the prolife argument

The argument of the prolife movement is that of right to life. According to wikipedia, "The right to life is the belief that a being has the right to live and, in particular, should not be killed by another entity including government." But the sentiment of "right to life" is highly misleading, specifically in the abortion debate. The defining factor for prolife is not life or death.  It's action. Herein lies the issue with the prolife argument. The prolife movement should have life at it's foundation. However, upon further examination, it actually has another foundational block underneath that, and that is about  preventing people from doing things that they deem as wrong.  It is about action vs inaction. If life can be saved through action, it is not permissible if it violates someone's bodily autonomy. Why? Because that would then involve  doing something wrong  (taking action.) But if life can be saved through inaction (such as banning abortion), it ...